Jack Daniel: Welcome.
I'm glad I'm not the only one thinking WKRP jokes. Just...I had to say
that. God is my witness, I thought turkeys could fly. I hadn't actually thought about doing this presentation
originally. This sort of came to me when I was at Ithaca College. We
would get a steady stream, I would say pretty much daily, of people
telling us--via Twitter usually, sometimes on Facebook--that "Wow,
Ithaca College just gets social media in higher ed! They get that they
have to actually talk to and with us." And I hadn't really thought about it as such. I just sort of
realized that when I was thinking about doing social media for the
College that I didn't know how to communicate without sounding like
somebody. It was there. So I started thinking about it and realized that,
unconsciously, I had really crafted something that was particularly the
institution, a voice that to me resonated with what Ithaca College
sounded like collectively. And apparently it resonated with a lot of
other people. |
|
01:08 |
So, anyway, that's what led me to this place. So, voice. What's a voice? And by the way, just so you know,
this is the fluff piece of the day. I'm probably not at medal
competition, but I'm like the Jamaican bobsledders over here. This will probably not change you institutional plan at all. But it's nice to
know. So what do you mean by 'voice'? The voice of your institution,
it's not so much the elevator speech but it's the tone and the cadence
of it. It's what sounds comfortable. It's what your various constituent
audience hear and think, 'Yeah, Ithaca. Yeah! That's good. I like that.
I'm comfy there. I remember that,' or 'I want to go there,' or 'I hope
my kid goes there.' So the voice is really a conversational extension of your
brand. It's all that work you spend doing brand identity, all that time
and effort to establish your marketing platform so that you could say,
"This is who we are. This is what we do. This is what we're about." And
it's turning that into someone who had all those
properties and then had to go to a cocktail party and discuss it. [Laughter] |
02:25 |
Jack Daniel: So how do
you determine that? How do you know what that is?
Well, there are a lot of factors, not the least of which is listening
to your environment. I grew up in Ithaca, New York and was at Ithaca College for
eight years. And I knew, simply by virtue of living there, just by
gleaning from the institution some pretty important things about it, a
few rules to that. Be true to your school. Know what it is that your
school does best. Ithaca College is a performance school. When I was a kid, I
knew three things about it: I knew that they did a lot of plays, I knew
that there were a lot of musicians, and I knew that they played
football because the coach lived across the street from me. |
03:07 |
And all three of those, that's people on a stage, that's
people performing, that's putting it out there. And once I started
working at Ithaca, it became clear to me that pretty much all of the
programs, everything that the institution did, everything that we
encouraged our students to do, was about performance. So having identified that, Ithaca's kind of showy. It's kind
of 'jazz hands'. And the only people who know that is because in your
tweets, in your Facebook post, what have you, you inflect this voice,
this sound. You're not afraid to be funny. You're not afraid to have a
little fun with people. And nothing sort of identifies you as a person
rather than a machine quite like humor. And talking like a person is
really essential. People are so used to this institutional edifice. They're so used to just running up against the wall. I mean, "Oh, that's the institution and I can't go there." |
04:03 |
They respond really positively if you give them something to
work with, and someone who's friendly and conversational and what not
can do that. You want them to be careful. You want to make sure
you're
matching tone for tone. Most people, when they're on Twitter or Facebook, they're just
kind of musing, especially on Twitter. And TweetDeck was like the
greatest invention in my life because I could just sort of put my ear
to the ground to hear what people were talking about Ithaca all over
the
place. And they would say things often just sort of idly, like, "Oh, I
miss Fall in Ithaca from when I was a student there." And you just put
up a little photo there of Fall in Ithaca and they get on musing and
give
you money, and it's great! It's a great way to talk to people. But they're not always just idly musing like that. Sometimes
it's
more serious. Sometimes they're going, "Oh, I can't register for
classes."
This is a chronic one that I see; there were some registration issues a
while back. "I can't register. I'm struggling. I'm up at 7 am. I can't
get my classes. This is a nightmare." So you change the voice a little
bit. You want to be
sympathetic and you want to be helpful. |
05:03 |
Tread lightly, because there are hot button issues out there.
And for whatever reason, there is always someone spoiling for a fight
someplace. Usually you can avoid it, usually you can deflect it, and
the fact is, if you've done the first three steps, you've made some
friends online, you have people who trust you as the voice of the
institution who identify with you, and they go from being potential
critics to being advocates. So that really makes a big difference when
you've got someone really pushing your buttons. That said, if someone's really got an issue, if it's a
legitimate concern, a gripe or like that, make sure you direct them to the
right people immediately and not try to solve it yourself. And finally, listen to direct feedback and the back channel.
They are two different kinds of feedback. People are a little more open
in one than the other. But it does help you shape the responses, help
you shape your voice in the next iteration as you're learning. It's
always evolving. It's always changing. If it's not working, you're
going to know about it. |
06:01 |
Why does it matter? Who cares, this voice? These kids, they
come to school, they give us the money, we teach them the stuff, they
learn and they go--what? What? Well, it isn't always that easy. Your institution doesn't
control the Web beyond your borders. People are already having these
conversations. This isn't optional. And most of you know this--you've
done this kind of stuff before--but the simple fact is, it never hurts
to repeat that we're not the ones controlling the message. The message existed long before us. And people were already
talking about it. We just have the capacity to actually listen now.
And so it's more important to be aware of how you engage with these
audiences. It's more important to notice what your tone is and how
you're responding. Do you sound sort of petulant because everybody's complaining
about the weather or the fact that the catalog is hard to read or what
have you? You don't want to get yourself in that situation. Broadcasting is hideous. And at my new job, where they're a
little behind in social media, they're sort of proud of themselves for
broadcasting
everything on Twitter and Facebook, and I'm just now getting to the
point where I can convince people, "Look, all you're doing is sending
out another news feed. You're not telling anybody anything they don't
already
know." |
07:13 |
Moreover, if you've gotten people on board, if you're in
conversation with people, if people have needs and you meet them, if
they
have concerns and you listen, they're going to listen to you and
they're going to like you. And then they'll take what you put out there
and then they'll push it out. Friendcasting is just the way we all get news now. I mean, I
do my best to read the paper everyday but the simple
fact is, half the stories I read someone forwarded to me on Facebook
or what have you. So we want to be one of those stories. And more than anything else, it's just another opportunity to
shake
your brand. The brand as you know is living. It's breathing. It's
always
changing in the hands of the consumers as well as those of us who are
trying to push it. And this is another way to engage people in an area
that maybe they're more comfortable with. |
08:00 |
People don't always say things when they come to your campus
and write on the comment cards or what have you, but they're thinking
them elsewhere. They're thinking them afterwards. And this is an
opportunity to engage them at that moment. Now once you start to establish the voice, once you get to
know where your voice is and what shapes it, you put yourself in a
position where you actually can address a whole bunch of different
issues. And when I was at IC, I found that Twitter for me was really
where I was the most comfortable in contending with audience issues,
concerns, things people were excited about, what have you. So these are just some of the examples that we did. We would
acknowledge new students. It's always important when people are out
there talking about, "Oh, I got in, I got in!" And they also probably
got into five or six other places that I wasn't following, but
there's no reason we can't engage them here. And this is one thing, every time someone you know, puts up a
little something, have a little fun
with them. But we had people come in the last couple of years who would
tell us, "You know, you guys are the only people who paid any attention
when I was excited about coming here. Nobody else was listening. Nobody
else engaged me." |
09:15 |
I had a mother who--some government mucky-muck in the state of
Massachusetts--had been musing about where her kid was going to go for
months. And at each point I just sort of interacted. And when he got
in, I said, "That's really great. I really think you guys will fit in
well here," blah blah blah. And in time the kid ended up coming, and
the mother told me, "You guys are the only ones who paid attention. No
one else was listening." It's an easy fix. Campus notifications are always good. You build these
elaborate systems and what not to get the message out, but a lot of
people are just following Twitter or Facebook. So, emergency
notification system. Try to look surprised. Academics. A little tough to push academics sometimes at 140
characters, but it can be done, especially the fun stuff. There's a lot
of fun stuff with Child Development Psychology kind of stuff at Ithaca.
So we would always push little bits like that. |
10:07 |
Be seasonally relevant. April Fool's Day is a lot of fun, and so
one year, because I couldn't do some big elaborate Web thing, I just
started doing a Twitter thing on one of our integrated courses because
we
were trying to do more interdisciplinary at IC. And so I said, "One of IC's new integrated courses, Literature
in the Age of Twitter, aims to discover the 140-character soul of great
works," EG, and then there were a whole bunch of them. This was kind of
my favorite, "Of Mice and Men". Oops. "Anna", we went for "Ulysses", and a bunch
of
others. "Ulysses" was fun, snuck in one word or two. And that led to some funny things and little back-and-forth.
When you start to take on the voice, people begin to interact with the
voice, and not just the institution, and it gets a little surreal, like
this one. This is in response to all the literature ones, this girl
wrote. [Laughter] |
11:02 |
Jack Daniel: And so
you've just got to roll with it, what you've got yourself in
there. And by the way, this wasn't anything--I wouldn't say that this
was officially sanctioned by the University that I started doing it
this way. [Laughter] Jack Daniel: We simply had a
conversation--there was a big committee on campus, a Facebook task
force that was in charge of social media policy and opportunities and
what not, and we put together a big proposal, and it died on somebody's
president's desk someplace. And there was a void. I just walked into
it. My boss was amenable and I was, "I'm going to go do this." "Go. It's
your ass." So we just did it, and it got a very favorable response. I
mean,
nothing succeeds like success, right? It wasn't called to anyone's
attention in
any sort of senior position until it was well on its way to doing
really well. It's always good to share your press. It's funny--people will
sort of idly complain about a school or about whatever, a job, until
they see something written about it in the mainstream press and then
they're like, "Yeah, it's my school! Yeah! My school! Wooh!" |
12:04 |
I live in the Deep South now and every Saturday afternoon
there's just a lot of "Wooh! My school! Wooh!" So I'm sort of adjusting
to that now. [Laughter] Jack Daniel: But this is
actually--it's funny to actually look at this. This is actually the
very last thing I ever tweeted for IC, and I only knew about it because
I was flying back and forth for this new job. This is a fun one. Do you know the peculiar habit people
have of blaming or cheering your school for things you cannot possibly
control? I just loved it. This was like a daily event that I'd see.
People
would muse about things, and the weather was a big one. People would
always say, "Why is it snowing?" "Why is it raining?" "Why is it too
sunny
today at Ithaca College?" "What have you done to me?" [Laughter] Jack Daniel: And this
one was funny. This was right after Cornell was in the Sweet 16 and
they lost. And we were like, "OK, get a grip. There's some
fun stuff going on in town." |
13:00 |
It snows a lot there. Not as much as Syracuse or someplace,
but it snows enough that people get irritated. And we got a huge mass
of complaints one day because we wouldn't close. And these are kids
who are like walking a hundred yards from the dorm to the dining hall.
We got people who work there who had to drive 30 miles
in from the country riding on the back of a snowplow. But they couldn't get their heads around it. So sometimes
you've just got to diffuse them a little bit, because if you get in a
pissing match with them, then you'll lose. Then the voice loses. You've
got to stay humble even when they give you the love. Awesome approach to it, yeah. Now, the opposite of humble is hubris. And the voice got kind
of big for me. I got to the point where I could sort of dream in the
voice a little bit and was thinking about it more often than I should
have. And so we were getting a lot of awards. Kids were winning all kinds of stuff, man--Fulbrights and things--and it seemed like there was just so many. And so I wanted to express the volume, the total volume of all these great awards and how we were just like inundated with this stuff. |
14:18 |
So I tweeted this. It took about 30 seconds before the first
one
came in: "So you're saying that the degrees are worthless the minute
they're printed?" [Laughter] Jack Daniel: "Oh, no!
I meant the volume and the number and"--oh, fuck it. [Laughter] I was
ruined. But, you know, it happens. It happens if you've got the feel
for it. You've got to kind of watch that it doesn't get away from you
because, yeah, the voice will turn on you. Now that
used to be the end. But then I moved, and I needed an epilogue. And
it's the only epilogue picture I could find. I don't know, what's in
that blog look like, right? [Laughter] |
15:11 |
Jack Daniel: I was
doing my thing there at Ithaca, and an opportunity came along. And I
had to say goodbye to beautiful, serene, sophisticated, hippy-laden
Ithaca and embrace the more beguiling charms of New Orleans... [Laughter] Jack Daniel: ...where
I
replaced this man as Director of Web Strategy at UNO. [Laughter] Jack Daniel: No,
that's a
joke. He works at Tulane. [Laughter] Jack Daniel: And it
struck me that I really didn't know the school. I found myself with a
handicap I've never had before. I knew about IC--I grew up 500 yards
from
the office I ended up working in. UNO, I didn't really have that
benefit. I knew a few things on paper. I knew that it was the first
integrated public university in the South. That's cool. |
16:00 |
I knew that it had a lot of really funky programs like Naval
Architecture and an Urban Planning program that is like the gold
standard right now because they've got a living lab. They've got a
300-year-old city they're rebuilding. It's kind of cool for them. And I knew that, by and large, it was the school that pretty
much created the middle class in New Orleans. It empowered a lot of
people who had always been outside--things changed a little slower down
there, and this was the school that really enabled a lot of people to
have a much more vibrant existence. But that was all I knew. I didn't know what the place sounded
like. It was always metaphors going around. People were always talking
about New Orleans, "Oh, New Orleans is..." and they would always invoke
the music and the food and gumbo. What the hell does gumbo sound like?
What are we going to do with that? So I found myself sort of in a bit of a crisis my first month
there. I was like, "Now what am I going to do?" This was my baby. And I
was like this kid, you know? Like, wait a minute. I
used to know how these things worked! [Laughter] |
17:10 |
Jack Daniel: And I
don't anymore. It took me a little while. And we had a little chaos.
Our chancellor was fired by the LSU board exactly one month after I got
hired. There was some bloodletting. And when things started to calm
down
a little bit, I sort of backed up a little bit. I got a little less
panicky. I thought, 'What do you know? Why do you know what you know
already and how can you work it here?' Again, listen all the time. It's a fairly big canvas, kind of
spread out. A lot of people don't actually live there. So I had to go
around and start poking my head in in figuring out what people were
doing. The alumni magazine--which isn't technically an alumni
magazine, but it's an alumni magazine--that's a great place to sort of
glean
what it is people are concerned about--not so much where the
articles are or what we're trying to promote, but what people are
actually really getting angry about. |
18:03 |
UNO switched to Division 3 this year, which angered a lot of
alums to the point that they probably played some role in the
chancellor's
dismissal. And the thing is, it was a D1 school that was getting like
500 people a game. Nobody was supporting it. No one was there.
The Chronicle of Higher Education said something like all but 14 D1
schools
lost money last year. Any sensible person would know, you don't spend
money when you
don't have it on huge stadiums that no one goes to. But people love it.
People who are vocal and people who spend money as alums really loved
being in D1. And so it's the kind of thing that shapes the tone of the
voice, because the voice can't be so flipping about it like, "Look,
jackass, you weren't going to win anything, anyway." You can't really
say that and tell them to embrace D3 like, "Ithaca College is a great
D3 athletics school." D3 in the Deep South, you might just as well be talking
Eskimo. They don't know what you're talking about. "D3 sports?
What?" If it's not on TV, if I can't be in the barn on Saturday,
"Wooh!"
it doesn't exist. |
19:11 |
So that's
part of the education right now. Attend the class, go to group
meetings, go to a protest, go to a pub crawl, something where you're
hearing people in the environment of the university, in the culture
that they are part of creating and changing at all times. And when all else fails, just break it down into something
they can
all agree on. Gumbo, maybe not so much, but jazz? "Yeah, jazz!" Jazz in
New Orleans, it's everywhere. You can't get away from it. It's in the
stores as you walk in. It's coming from--it's in the airport, for God's
sake. And everywhere you go, it's playing constantly--except this one
coffee shop up by UNO that's playing cheesy fusion. I just want to
shake them like, "You live in New
Orleans, for the love of God!" [Laughter] Jack Daniel: "Will
Louis Armstrong kill you? Jeez, Louise!" So that's the voice. That's 'Guided by Voices'. And I'll take
any questions you might have. |
20:06 |
Audience 1: What
happened to the Ithaca Twitter account when you left? Audience 2: Could you
repeat the question? Jack Daniel: Oh, I'm
sorry. And there's a mic up here. You all might want to try
and--because we're doing podcasting. Not to get you out of your
seat...but get out of your seat. Audience 1: What
happened to the Ithaca Twitter account when you left? Did your voice
scale for the institution, or when you left, was the sort of
humor and humanity gone? Jack Daniel: They
dragged it out to the back and shot it. No. [Laughter] Jack Daniel: No,
actually it was funny. There was a young guy that got hired in a
different position, actually, who had been one of our biggest boosters
on Twitter and on Facebook, when he didn't even work at IC. And he'd
been hired a few months earlier. And he was just sort of a natural on the slot in because
part of
what had attracted him to the school was the fact that
he felt we really got social media. So he was sort of a natural one to
slip into that. I believe they're actually hiring a permanent person
who this will be part of, and this was just a little part of
what I did,
but I think someone else will probably end up doing it. |
21:09 |
Yeah, it seems to have translated pretty well. People
expected it. People got used to a certain friendliness and a certain
boosterism but in that kind of tongue-in-cheek kind of way without it
just
being sort of straight-up blah-blah, rah-rah. And I think that will
help transition anyone into that spot. Anybody else? All right. Well, thank you very much--oh, one more. Moderator: Nope, I'm
going to bring you a mic that I hope... This working? It
is working. Audience 3: You work
in the Web Development Department, correct? Jack Daniel: I'm the
Director of Web Strategy, so I'm in Marketing. Audience 3: OK. How
much does Admissions play in the Twitter field, both back at Ithaca or
at the new place? |
22:04 |
Jack Daniel: At
Ithaca, it didn't, initially. And I know that there's been some talk
there about how they might better do that. The Marketing and Communications
team at Ithaca College was sort of based on the idea of centralizing
marketing control and taking it out of the exclusive hands
of--the Admissions still plays a very big role there. It's a
tuition-driven
school much like UNO. And much of this comes down to personalities of individuals
involved and making friends. Relationship management is everything,
just like it is anywhere else in an institution, but getting by and
pretty much came from a) the fact that no one else was doing it and b)
much of the messaging came down to things that weren't specific to
Admission. Ithaca College is very integrated with the community, with the
city of Ithaca. Obviously there's a healthy alum support. So it's not
just recruitment all the time. So we wanted to be in a sort of
centralized position. |
23:03 |
Now that said, I would often, during various points in the
cycle, go to the Marketing and Communications person who handles the
Admissions account and get from her things that are timely, what have
you. There's nothing wrong with being timely and really staying on top
of it, and you can integrate that into the voice, you know? Audience 4: How often
did you tweet? Jack Daniel: I would
try to do it at least a couple of times a day. You can flood. I mean,
as we're seeing with the HeWeb10, it's pretty easy to saturate. But
also, too much would get to the point of becoming a distraction, I
think, for me, personally, because I would just be trying to be clever
all the damn time and it would invariably bite me in the ass. So I
really wanted to keep it sort of to a minimum. But also, it's just easier to maintain like that. I mean, how
many pithy statements to you really come up with in the course of a
day? So I tried to keep it to a minimum. |
24:07 |
I've seen in a couple of cases that I see at least--and now it
seems to be a little bit more active, although that may be specific to
given days where they're doing programming. I know they did the big
Moving Day where they had a lot of people tweeting in about moving
day. But that seems like it was really successful. Yeah. Audience 5: Do you use
a special program to find out who are talking about you, who are
tweeting about you? Do you aggregate that kind of information? Jack Daniel: I
aggregated it only in so far as I would keep track for my own purposes
of ongoing kinds of conversations. And then I would sort of annotate,
is this is a parent or is this is a student or is this is an
alum kind of thing. So, no. No particular software. More just me sort
of being sort of grandfathering it, you know? Moderator: Now, kind
of
related to that--is anybody here using a paid listening solution like
Radian6 at their institution? Somebody? Wow. I've been asking this
question for a year, you're the first one I've seen who has done that.
So how does it work? |
25:14 |
Audience 6: I worked
in the Admissions office... and they used it every once in a
while, but... Moderator: All right.
I've been actually having conversations with Radian6 because their
pricing structure doesn't fit in with my absolutely zero budget. [Laughter] Moderator: So I needed
to see the value beyond something like social mention or building--I
have built a Netvibes page at my institution. It just pulls in
everything that's happening out there. And I've been yet to be
convinced by Radian6 that it's worth the extra money, so I'm still...
To me, I'm really interested when higher ed actually starts to do that. So another question here. Audience 7: Did you
monitor any of your competitor schools' Twitter feeds-- Jack Daniel: Yeah, a
little bit. Audience 7: --to
kind of differentiate, to make sure you were differentiating yourself
from them? |
26:03 |
Jack Daniel: Yeah, a
little bit. Obviously you can't do anything at Ithaca without being
aware of Big Red. I mean, they're just...it consumes all the oxygen in
the room, basically. They're just huge. They suck at Twitter. They've
gotten a little better, but...and in fact, I remember one day, they put
one out--and I can't actually remember what it was about but it was
funny and
it was so...I was so surprised that it was funny that we were tweeting
like, "Hey, look who lightened up!" [Laughter] Jack Daniel: Had to
mess with them a little bit. Look, they got a huge endowment; they
don't need me. But, yeah. When we started, it wasn't too far away from when
Colgate decided they were going to have a kid tweeting the entire year,
like a freshman. I think they had it on the homepage. And it was an
interesting idea. It wasn't fully fleshed out. But I was aware of it,
and so that was kind of what spawned me to actually just start
thinking about, 'I want to know what other people are saying,'
especially in the region, because we're all kind of living in the same
spot and there's a lot of schools jammed in that area. |
27:11 |
But by and large, it was impressive to me just how distinct
the
Ithaca College voice was and how much it didn't really bear a lot of
resemblance to anything around. And I'm hoping to find that, and I'm starting to now, at UNO.
I mean, the thing with UNO is, in the wake of Katrina, for whatever
reason--well, I know the reason: because they got the money--Tulane has
really sort of insinuated themselves in the space of, "We are the
higher
ed voice of a recovering city." And their president, Scott Cowen, is
a really bright guy and he's done a really good job of making sure that
he's sort of front and center for these conversations. We, on the other hand, haven't really had that. Our chancellor
really fought hard for the school in the wake of Katrina. I suspect it
might've taken a real toll on him, and this is the guy who went in in a
rowboat with a couple of state troopers to manually get out all
the drives that held all the payroll information, the financial aid
information, all that kind of stuff, because it was all living on
campus. |
28:14 |
But in terms of managing the PR side, in terms of
insinuating himself into the conversation that the University of New
Orleans is the university for New Orleans and for the people of New
Orleans, it hasn't quite got there yet. But the voice, the core
elements of it exist, and it's probably up to me to a certain extent to
shape them and to begin to really project that. Audience 8: What about
multiple voices? I live in-- Jack Daniel:
Schizophrenia? [Laughter] Audience 8: Yes! I've
been asked to, in addition to myself tweeting as a student leader
and adviser leader, did you come out was schizophrenic? Jack Daniel: Yeah. I
mean, the question, if you didn't hear it, was multiple Twitter on
campus. |
29:01 |
NC State is the gold standard of this. Anybody who's sort of
followed this, really--NC State has this extraordinary aggregation of
all these
tweets that's coming in. I find it actually overwhelming. I'm sure some
people just love it. I just... I try to follow it, and I don't know
enough
about the institution to feel like I can really engage with it. But
what they've done is really impressive. We had a bunch of different people at IC tweeting.
It's not so much at UNO. Actually, there are a few, but they're mostly
just doing broadcast. But there are quite a few that I see. What I found is that if I engaged them, they sort of
recognized that some voices are more equal than others. Once
they realized that we were sort of the main thing, we would engage, and
the stuff that mattered, that they did, they would begin to sort of
adopt
the voice a little bit and it became easier to then retweet it, push it
out,
get the messaging out there. |
30:00 |
The thing is, with social media, and I've been saying--I've
been in social media a long time. I was at Bolt 10 years ago, long
before Zuckerberg was out of his nappies. The thing about social media
is it works best when people are already likely to engage in it. You
know what I mean? If you're not comfortable with it, you can't really
superimpose a solution on it. "Simon says you need to have this kind
of person in there." It's kind of hard to go out like, "I'm going to
purchase one of
these kind of people in the bookstore and stick them in front of the
monitor and they will do as I say." It doesn't really work that way. I'm not entirely sure why it is most of us can be trained to
do a lot of things, but for whatever reason, when it comes to being
conversational, it's not something you can just sort of superimpose. So, I think it can work. I think the NC State model is a good
example of a site where they've really taken their time to pull in all
these different voices. I don't know what that sounds like
institutionally, like I don't know if you can say, "That is an easily
identifiable quality," "That is North Carolina State." I just know it
sounds like a whole lot of people on that campus tweeting and musing
and what not. Yeah. |
31:12 |
Audience 9: Moving on
to that question. Do you think it's important for schools to take a
segment of the population and target them? Like, is it important to
target
prospective students or to target, for instance, their
alumni or...? Jack Daniel: Yeah. The
question is basically, is it important for the institution to pick a
given demographic, a given audience, like prospective students, and
target
them? That's actually a much bigger question than social media.
That's, again, a question of school identity, and it's one of these to
be sorted out at a higher level. Obviously, if you're in a school like Ithaca or a school like
UNO
where enrolment really determines what the budget looks like every
year, you're going to spend a little extra time making sure that
recruitment and yield--yield in particular, I find, because yield is
where you're selling, that yield is where the conversation really
matters. |
32:02 |
If people know about your school enough to apply, you can't
really sway them--I mean, you can a little bit, but yield, I'll tell
you a little yield story. There was a kid who had been really actively
musing on Twitter about Ithaca College for the better part of a year.
And he would compare it to other schools. He was thinking about RIT, some
other places. And I loved it. He was complaining about the weather in
Ithaca but he was talking about going to RIT. I'm like, "Pal, you
have no idea what you're getting yourself into." [Laughter] Jack Daniel: And it
went on. And he would just say the quirkiest things about it, like why
he wasn't pressing the gas because I would sort of initially be like, "Oh,
yeah, come on and apply. It's a great campus. It's a beautiful, cool
school." And that was not having the effect that it usually has. And finally, just in the moment of idle curiosity, I looked at
his Twitter profile and I clicked, he had a blog. And he was from
suburban
Philadelphia or someplace. He was a straight-edge kid. And someone had
told him that there was some crazy drug culture at Ithaca and that
everyone was just working the bong 24/7 and
what not. [Laughter] |
33:12 |
Jack Daniel: It's
actually only during daylight hours. No one knew that, but... [Laughter] Jack Daniel: And so he
had it built up in his head that, like, "Oh my God, I'm going to this
place. They're all these crazy juggies and what not." And all I did was
I tweeted him, "If you're interested, here's some information about our
substance-free housing." And the kid wrote back and he was like, "I
wouldn't
have even known to ask that." And so he ended up coming, which we all
wish he didn't because he was a pain in the ass after that. [Laughter] Jack Daniel: Uptight
little school boy. But in the course of it, it was cool
because this was--I had to think like a recruiter but I also had to
think about, what's his life going to be like here? How do you
keep some of this? Because everybody knows, man: it's cheaper to keep
them than to go get some more. And recruitment has always been a big
issue for us there. |
34:05 |
So, yeah. Audience 10: Hi.
Greetings from Cornell University. Jack Daniel: Woohoo! [Laughter] Jack Daniel: Woohoo!
Come on, you guys learned it. It's the Sweet 16, there's the little
'woohoo'. I heard it. Audience 10: I've got
a
couple of questions for you. One of them is about Twitter and sort of
the younger generation, if you've done any research or aware of any
good research about if these kids are using it? Obviously you think so,
but I'd like to hear more about that. And-- Jack Daniel: Yeah.
It's definitely... A few years back, that was sort of the joke with
Twitter. It was like, finally someone invented a social media that only
fogies used, and the kids weren't into it. I had a spectacularly
drawn-out discussion-slash-argument with the new president at Ithaca
College about Twitter one day--one day, one month, one year--wherein he
could simply not get his head around the fact that there was this
social media tool that didn't cater just to kids. Like he just assumed,
out of the gate, that it didn't. |
35:19 |
And so it took a little while to get that point across. And
then by the time I did, kids were starting to sort of grab on to it
finally. Everything I've read is that it's trending younger and
younger. Now that said, they're not the only audience. And at UNO,
actually, it's particularly important to recognize because we do have a
lot of older students. Out median age is considerably higher than a lot
of other state schools. It's traditionally a school for working-class
folks in New Orleans, many from working jobs, takes them a little
longer to get there, takes them a little longer to get through it. So that's a big piece of it knowing that the demographic isn't
as rigidly defined as 17-year-olds. But their parents, who
remain their biggest influencers, are actively engaged. |
36:04 |
And more and more--I would say, each year that I see, I
noticed the kids increasing by a significant factor. Not just a couple
more trickling in, but the time I left, they definitely held sway. They
were definitely the main group that was responding. But there was also
sort of just out there idling, musing about the school and about
conversations they wanted to have at school but didn't know who to ask,
posting questions about financial aid on Twitter, posting them on
Facebook. So they're there. They're definitely there increasingly. It
may come down to the sort of things that they're interested in. Kids
who don't really necessarily know exactly what kind of program they
want to follow seem to be really actively musing about, "I don't know
what to do in college. Can you help me, Ithaca?" Audience 10: Here, I
do
have some data. I am involved with the Noel Levitz' E-Expectation
Survey which we do every year of college-bound high school seniors. |
37:03 |
And I've been adding social media questions to that survey for
the last couple of years. Last year, when we asked that group, "Are you
on Twitter or not?" 8% said yes. This was a telephone survey
throughout the country, college-bound high school seniors. When we asked that question the year before, it statistically
did not even register. It was 3 out of over 1,000 respondents
said they were on Twitter in 2009. Last year it was like 85 out of
1,000. So you can look at that any way you want. One, only 8%; the
other way, look at how much it's increased over the course of a year.
So we will be asking that question again next springtime-- Jack Daniel: Did you
parse your data as to whether or not they were necessarily
college-bound?
Because they're a broad-- Audience 10: They are
college-bound. At least by the definition of 'as good as we can
tell'. Jack Daniel: Right. Audience 10: And
that's
country--we actually see some variation in terms of demographics, both
geographic and ethnic demographics, so-- |
38:02 |
Jack Daniel: Yeah. And
that's true for a lot of tools. I mean, I think I waited just long
enough to move down south for MySpace to die off. Thank God. So I have
to deal with that. But if I'd gone a year or two earlier, they
would've been insistent about MySpace. Audience 10: And
MySpace still exists in the Southwest. Jack Daniel: And it
does. It absolutely does in their schools. All the schools that ever
did anything with it that was remotely successful were in the South.
Auburn had a
huge page. Moderator: OK. We have
time for a couple more questions. Let me... Jack Daniel: Way over
on the side there. Audience 11: Do you
focus primarily on, well, obviously Facebook and Twitter, but are there
any other social networks that you're looking at or... I mean, there's
YouTube and
others but-- Jack Daniel: Some.
Yeah. Audience 11: --what's
coming down the road, etcetera? Jack Daniel: YouTube
is a little tricky that I see because it wasn't always clear exactly
whose shop it was sitting in. |
39:06 |
There was some instructional technology people who had...we
would try to work together. Sourcing was a little hard. It's a little
harder to get good
video source material because there's a lot of video on
campus--obviously they've got a huge film production--but people are a
little
territorial about it, as you would expect. It's their work. So I've primarily focused on Facebook and Twitter. The rubber
hits the road sooner there. There's a lot... It's very democratic
tools,
very easily accessible. I had actually this year hoped to put together
something on location-based media, and then Tim Nekritz and a bunch
of other brilliant people beat me to it and would do it exponentially
better than I ever would. I also couldn't figure out... At IC, there were like five
people
who were on Foursquare. You become, "Your mayorship's changed." It was
like a Banana Republic. [Laughter] |
40:01 |
Jack Daniel: It was
just one coup after another. So I sort of missed out on having an
opportunity do that. I had a student worker, she went to South by
Southwest and then came back, "Oh my God, Foursquare's amazing!
Everybody's involved, people all over the place!" I'm like, "Yeah, you
couldn't fill a bathroom on this campus with the people who are using
it." So it's not worth it. But it's something I'm definitely interested in because I
know it's going to happen. Especially in a place like UNO, campus is
still recovering from the storm. The area around it was actually much
worse hit. It's hard to find lunch, you know? So, a good location-based
media can sort of enhance the living experience there. All right. One more. Moderator: Yeah, one
more question. Jack Daniel: One more. Audience 12: Do you
post simultaneously to Facebook and Twitter the same message or do you
have a slightly different tenor or voice on Facebook? Jack Daniel: The voice
does sort of modulate based on what kind of conversation you're likely
to get into. |
41:03 |
Twitter remains Twitter, and it's still going to be kind of
brief and punchy and what not. You can get a little get more involved
than Facebook, and I certainly intended to. And the tone would be a
little more engaging in the sense of welcoming, like expanding the
conversation for that space. So, yeah, it does alter a little bit. I would try and mix up
the actual message so it is not an identical post, just for the sake
of--my own sake, I don't know why. It just seemed like the right thing
to do. OK. Hey, guys, thanks a lot. I know it's early in the morning,
we're all so sleepy, especially me, but thanks for coming down. [Applause] |